Harriet Martin - Cofton Junior
School, Birmingham
first published in MicroScope Information Handling Special 1997
As CD-ROM systems enter primary schools, teachers are searching to find the most
effective ways for their pupils to use the machines. The information disks available,
especially the encyclopaedias, are potentially extremely powerful resources. As with any
new technology, however, there are problems and many primary schools are finding it
difficult to realise the full potential of these powerful information systems. CD-ROMs
allow children to "paddle about" in an immense pool of information. If children
are to do more than paddle, what skills will they need to master?
Many of the skills needed to use CD-ROMs effectively are the universal research skills
which children need in order to become effective handlers of information presented in any
format. Whatever the medium used - books, tapes, videos, computers - research of any
nature involves four steps:
- define what information is desired (set goals, devise questions)
- find the information
- record the information (take notes)
- present the information in a new format (written report, picture, etc).
Children using CD-ROMs most effectively will be going through these four steps. I shall
consider each step in turn and propose some suggestions for developing the necessary
skills.
1 Setting Goals and Devising Questions
Teaching children to research "project" work well is a very challenging task.
In many primary classrooms project work is either largely unmonitored and pursued in
isolation from skills instruction or so highly directed that it is not really research at
all. To find out all you can about the Vikings, for example, is not a specific enough goal
and is likely to result in the waste of much time and effort.
Children must learn how to devise questions before they can find answers. This is
extremely important. Effective learning is more likely to occur when reading is focused,
when the reader has a clear goal in mind, a clear question to answer. The question may be
testing an idea (eg Is it true that all the largest dinosaurs lived towards the end of the
dinosaur age?) or it may seek data (eg Where was Alfred Lord Tennyson born and brought
up?).
Questioning skills include:
- the ability to review existing knowledge as prelude to questioning (eg What do we
already know about fighting in Tudor times?)
- the ability to formulate questions which can be answered (eg What kind of weapons did
the Tudors use?)
- the ability to formulate hypothesis which can be tested (eg Is it true that the Tudors
had no knowledge of explosives and therefore could not use weapons such as guns or
grenades?).
In the early years the teacher may ask a question or set a problem for the children to
solve but this should only be a preliminary step towards children setting their own goals.
Techniques for helping children order their preexisting knowledge and devise questions for
research include:
- Brainstorming
- Think of relevant words about the topic and then group these into
areas. Select a word from each area and use a questioning word (who, where, why, how,
when, what) to make a question. Children work in pairs to make as many questions as
possible. Put these aside for a few days then children sort the questions crossing out
those which would be too hard to answer. Finally they select two questions to find the
answers to, working as a pair with a book or CD-ROM.
- Mapping
- Make a map or diagram of all we already know about a topic. Indicate where
new information will fit on and formulate questions to find this new information. Add the
new information to the diagram after research.
2 Finding the Information
Finding information generally involves using organisational devices such as contents
pages or an index to locate material, skimming to gain an overall impression, scanning to
pick out relevant information and detailed reading to answer a specific question. Having
learned the alphabet children learn to use it to order words and to find words by letter
order. This is the key to using dictionaries and indexes. The 1991/2 HMI English report
suggests basic skills in this area need some attention in many schools. Dictionary skills
are not always taught effectively and there is marked variation in the degree to which
pupils are taught to use the contents pages or index of reference books. Children need to
be aware of these entrance paths to books and encyclopaedias.
In practice teachers encounter a number of difficulties if they ask children to devise
their own questions and then look up answers to them using children's books.
- Many school and class libraries do not have enough books on a given topic to make it
probable that most of the children will find the answers to their questions.
- Many children's books lack tables of contents - one study found that only 61% had
contents pages.
- Many children's books lack indexes. In the same study, only 58% of the books had
indexes. Furthermore many of the references cited in the indexes gave only passing
mentions to the topics. They were hard to find on the page and uninformative when found.
- Too few books make effective use of subheadings in the text as tools to focus attention,
clarify organisation and help retention of information.
- Children may have difficulty in thinking of a likely key word to look up. It is often
necessary to think of alternative words and the ability to do this is limited by the
child's vocabulary.
- Children need to have a reasonable idea of how to spell the words they are looking for.
- Children need to be able to read effectively for information. Children see
"good" readers as those who can concentrate, reading many pages in a session
without skipping and reading a book to its end. This technique is suitable for narrative
reading, the kind children are introduced to most frequently, but the reading of
non-narrative, factual material benefits from other skills.
CD-ROMs use a variety of organisational devices, some familiar such as alphabetical
indexes, and some new, such as keyword searches, menus and buttons. Children need to be
taught to use these search techniques, in particular keyword searches which may not be
clearly signalled on the menu pages. But, for the most part, the skills they are required
to use when finding information on a CD-ROM are similar to those required for text based
materials.
Skills for finding information include:
- the ability to identify appropriate sources of information
- the ability to use contents, indexes, chapter headings, subheadings, glossaries etc.
- the ability to skim and scan for required information.
Given all the difficulties mentioned above, teachers may need to take most of the first
step upon themselves, offering children only a limited set of materials which have been
vetted for their accessibility. In my own experience l have felt it helpful to devise
worksheets to match questions to a book or CD-ROM before asking the children to find the
answers using the index, contents page or menus. It is easiest to start with the source
material, find an interesting word, look up the reference and see if it is informative,
then write a question that the reference will answer. This technique gives the children a
fair level of success, but it is hardly realistic to suggest these children are doing
their own research. They are, however, learning how to use indexes and other search tools.
Similarly, skimming and scanning skills can be developed using carefully selected texts
or CD-ROMs which make good use of subheadings and other organisational strategies such as
text linked to pictures or words printed in bold fonts. Use of a good dictionary or
thesaurus can help children to check spellings and find synonyms and, incidentally, to
develop their vocabulary.
3 Recording information - Note Taking and Planning from Notes
Research should not mean copying. It should involve taking notes from the resources
studied and then rearranging these notes, using them as the framework for a new exposition
of knowledge.
Beyond doubt this is one of the most difficult tasks faced by young researchers.
Reading strategies among primary children are very often of an all-inclusive, unselective
nature. Similarly, in general, primary children do not establish writing goals in their
non-narrative writing, but use trial and error memory searches, setting down everything
they know about a topic in a non-systematic way. They usually start writing tasks with
very little thought or planning and if asked to extend their writing, they use association
to attach more data to that already included. This is a linear, low-level approach to
writing with little or no planning or goal setting. It fails to distinguish essential
detail from supporting, peripheral information.
Children have difficulty in planning and organising their own thoughts, but this is a
relatively easy task compared to reading someone else's writing, making notes from it, and
reconstituting it in one's own planning. It is hardly surprising that children tend to
copy when they "make notes". Even if they manage to reword sentences, the
organisation of the material is almost always copied. Notes made by a ten year old tend to
be complete ideas or sentences. Typically they write them down in their finished essay in
the same order in which they thought of them or noted them, although as many as half of
the notes may be elaborated or combined. When asked to plan, older students can produce a
plan; younger ones produce text. For this reason brainstorming is difficult for younger
children because they produce whole sentences, not words.
Organising collections of items or describing them to others is a new skill for
children that needs to be taught. Children up to and including 10 years of age find
independent planning and note taking almost insurmountably difficult but in the National
Curriculum these skills appear in the KS2 Reading Programme of Study. At level 5 children
are required to "retrieve and collate information from a range of sources" and
at level 6 they should be able to "summarise a range of information from different
sources".
Note taking and planning skills include:
- the ability to select relevant words and ideas in a text to answer a predetermined
question
- the ability to record these words in a way (possibly a table or matrix) which indicates
their relevance and importance.
- the ability to use these structured notes as a basis for planning.
A number of strategies can be used to develop these skills. The first three involve
working with printouts from a CD-ROM or photocopies of a text.
- Underlining
- Ask a question and underline a limited (say 15) number of words on a
page which answer it. Work in pairs and agree on the best words to underline. Compare, as
a class, what words were chosen. List the words on scrap paper for use as notes. Leave for
a few days before writing up.
- Multiple Underlining
- Use different colours to underline or highlight words to
answer different questions. For example, in a text about Stone Age times, use blue for
words about food, green for words about weapons, orange for words about homes, purple for
words about how life was different. Then rebuild the words into an information tree before
beginning to write.
- Crossing Out
- Cross out non-essential words in the text. Use what remains as notes.
Leave for a few days before writing up.
- Tabulation
- Read for information to fill in a table prepared by the teacher working
in pairs. Underlining can be used to highlight the information. Only three or four words
should go in each cell. Children can use separate sheets for each column to make the task
easier. A number of different source materials may be used to complete the table. Children
should put away tabulations for several days before writing.
4 Presenting Information in a New Format
Children start their literate lives reading narrative stories and writing narrative
text themselves. Writing text which informs rather than tells a story is a more difficult
task. It is rarely attempted before KS2.
Writing which presents information gleaned from a number of sources can only emerge if
note taking skills are developed as outlined above. A child who can do this well is
working at NC Level 5. Children are unlikely to reach this level before the final years of
KS2 and many, indeed probably the majority, will not achieve this before secondary school.
There are a number of features of informative writing which make it so much more
difficult. Information texts have very different linguistic structures from
story/narrative texts. They are more likely to have complex sentences, to use the passive
voice and to have long series of prepositional phrases which tax short term memory. In
addition words may be used in unusual contexts and with unusual meanings (eg "a polar
bear's coat commands a price"). Frequently verbal meanings are transferred to nouns
(eg "distribution of brown bears").
Children find it difficult to unpick these structures when reading informational texts
and nigh on impossible to emulate them when writing their own. This leaves them without a
useful model for their own work. Furthermore, informative, non-narrative writing is more
difficult because there is no story line to suggest an order.
Development of mature writers is a slow and tenuous process extending throughout the
school years. A writer requires four types of knowledge:
- a data base for writing (the substance)
- a procedural knowledge for recalling, ordering and transforming the data
- a knowledge of writing forms
- the ability to search for and find the appropriate form for the writing at hand.
The skills involved are numerous and complex. Many writers need explicit instruction in
the writing process; they do not learn it automatically. This is particularly true with
non-narrative writing. Children read fiction predominantly. A reading survey of all 180
children in Cofton Junior School revealed that 2/3 of the boys and 3/4 of the girls prefer
fiction to non-fiction in their own reading. Children also are more likely to write from a
personal point of view, describing what has happened as a story rather than describing it
in the impersonal register of non-fiction text.
Skills required for presenting information in a new format include:
- the ability to distinguish between essential information and supporting detail
- the ability to collect and order relevant data from a number of places
- the ability to use collected information to test hypothesis and draw conclusions: i.e.
turn data into information.
- the ability to structure information
- the ability to evaluate information collected
- the ability to make global connections.
Many of the note taking techniques outlined above can be used to help children develop
an order for their final writing. Most will lead straight into writing if only one
reference source is used. Tabulation is particularly useful if children are combining
material from several reference sources. Other techniques include
- Summarising or Outlining
- This can be useful in a supported fashion with children
of ten or eleven. For example, the teacher could give some main headings and ask children
to fill in one or two ideas under each heading. Then children could be asked to think of
some more headings for a later part of the text. Young children find it very difficult to
outline or summarise effectively on their own and even by ten or eleven the summaries are
often inadequate. Without support children usually give up and just copy the text.
- Working Towards a Meaningful End Product
- It is always helpful if children can see
a reason for their writing. For example, children could produce information books for a
younger age group.
- Writing the First Sentence/Paragraph
- The first sentence or paragraph of an
informational text is often a pointer to what is to come. A strategy for writing this is
to begin by writing as many words as come to mind on the chosen topic, then grouping the
words into similar categories and naming each group (homes, food, weapons etc). The
starting sentence or paragraph should then include all the category names.
- Producing a Desk-Top-Published or Multimedia Presentation
- While traditional
information books present a model of non-narrative writing which children find difficult
to copy, more modern forms of presentation offer alternative structures which might be
easier to emulate given the appropriate resource tools. A magazine or comic book approach
with short blocks of text mixed with pictures, diagrams etc can be created by manual
cut-and-paste or using a desk-top publishing package on a computer. On-screen multimedia
presentations can be produced using many of the same techniques and also many new ones,
such as use of buttons to move from page to page and the inclusion of sound clips.
There are no quick and easy solutions to the problem of developing children's
informational writing. Desk-top publishing work and the development of multimedia
presentations are extremely time consuming activities and it is not easy to find space for
them in a crowded curriculum. However, the benefits can be considerable in terms of both
skills development and motivation. Children find researching material and including it in
their own non-narrative writing very challenging. If the product of their work is a
multimedia presentation which can be viewed by other children, or by parents at open
evening, they will be more likely to be stimulated to meet the challenge.
